What did you think of The Book of Three Chapter 5 The Broken Sword by Lloyd Alexander?

#amreading #middlegrade #bookreview #fantasy #Book #ChapterXChapter #PrydainChronicles #FOTRESSFICTION

VIDEO

How To Read

The book can be borrowed FREE from CloudLibrary and in audiobook format, or your local library or purchased from the publisher’s site and many online retailers including in audiobook format as well from KOBO, audible.

WIKI – The Chronicles of Prydain

TOPICS

Soft Magic: The Grass Net; Achren’s Touch

Achren’s Duality

Gwydion’s Respect

Taran’s Courage

Silent Horror

---

“This lad can barely keep his feet.”

-Queen Achren, THE BOOK OF THREE CHAPTER 5

---

Soft Magic and Broken Swords: Analyzing Chapter 5 of The Book of Three

The Appeal of Soft Magic Systems

The magic system Lloyd Alexander employs in The Prydain Chronicles is decidedly “soft,” and this approach serves the narrative exceptionally well. By “soft magic,” I mean that readers don’t fully understand the mechanics, origins, or exact applications of magical elements in the story.

This approach aligns perfectly with how Gandalf operates in Tolkien’s works and mirrors the magical elements in George MacDonald’s “The Princess and the Goblin” and “The Princess and Curdie.”

I once preferred hard magic systems, but as my reading expanded and I began incorporating magic into my own writing, I discovered that soft magic systems offer unique narrative advantages. They preserve mystery and wonder in ways that more rigidly defined systems sometimes cannot.

Hard vs. Soft Magic

For contrast, consider Larry Correia’s “Hard Magic” (not a children’s book). Correia, author of the Monster Hunter International series and the Grimnoir Chronicles, treats magic as systematic and reveals its origins, defining it as something finite rather than infinite.

This stands in stark contrast to the grass net that Gwydion uses in Chapter 5, a technique he learned from Dallben. Gwydion clearly possesses magical capacity, but Alexander deliberately keeps the specifics ambiguous.

The Mystery of Achren’s Powers

Achren’s magical abilities remain similarly undefined. At one point, she appears to be healing Taran, or perhaps making him more susceptible to revealing vital information. Gwydion recognizes her enchantment attempt and interrupts before she can complete it.

Later in the chapter comes a truly terrifying demonstration of power when Achren attempts to break Gwydion’s sword. She crashes it against a pillar, throws it to the floor, and finally grabs the naked blade with her bare hand. Despite her bleeding hands, she breaks the sword amid sounds of thunder and flashes of lightning.

Her ominous declaration that she will break Gwydion just as she broke his sword creates a chilling moment. During this sequence, her eyes roll back and she mutters unintelligible words, heightening the mysterious nature of her power.

The Effectiveness of Soft Magic

This approach to magic echoes classic sword and sorcery tales where magic appears as mysterious, dangerous, and something to be feared, reminiscent of Robert E. Howard’s Conan or Solomon Kane stories.

In worlds with soft magic systems, readers observe magic’s effects and capabilities without understanding its mechanics. Authors often intentionally obscure these elements rather than explaining them.

This technique proves remarkably effective at maintaining wonder and awe. Like Taran, readers question exactly how Gwydion created the grass net. Similarly, Achren’s power to destroy the sword inspires both fear and fascination. By keeping the mechanics mysterious, Achren becomes all the more frightening.

Achren’s Dangerous Duality

Achren’s duality forms another unsettling element of this chapter. She concludes the chapter from a position of power, making threats and asserting control over Taran and Gwydion. Yet she begins with deceptive softness, remarking that “this lad can barely keep his feet” about Taran, expressing concern for his injuries, and suggesting their predicament must be “a terrible mistake.”

This strategic softness merely conceals the steel beneath—”an iron fist with a velvet glove.” She hints at “other ways to negotiate” when speaking to Gwydion, creating an undercurrent of menace that younger readers might not fully grasp but that adult readers will certainly recognize.

Taran’s Courage in the Face of Danger

When Gwydion creates an opportunity for Taran to escape, Taran refuses to flee. Instead, he stands his ground and fights alongside Gwydion, even landing a blow against one of the Cauldron-Born.

After the confrontation, Gwydion questions why Taran didn’t run and expresses both gratitude and respect for his bravery, even while acknowledging that flight might have been wiser. Though Taran’s decision demonstrates impulsiveness, it also reveals genuine courage. This exchange elegantly illustrates both characters’ natures and the developing dynamics between them.

The Silent Horror of the Cauldron-Born

The Cauldron-Born represent another masterful element of this chapter. Their silent menace creates genuine horror. When Gwydion stabs one through the heart, the creature simply shakes off the wound and continues fighting.

They neither speak nor tolerate speech from others, carrying whips at their waists to enforce silence. When Taran attempts to speak with Gwydion, a Cauldron-Born immediately silences him with a lash.

We learn that Arawn Death-Lord has “driven all humanity and all memory of joy” from these creatures. They exist now as empty shells with combat proficiency but no remaining humanity. Alexander subtly suggests they might resent the humanity and camaraderie they can witness but no longer experience, as they repeatedly silence their prisoners throughout the journey.

The profound implications of their condition create a uniquely disturbing aspect of the narrative that effectively establishes them as both threatening and tragic.

Conclusion: The Book Keeps Getting Better

This chapter represents another strong installment in “The Book of Three.” With each section, Alexander’s world becomes richer and more engaging. The blend of danger, courage, and mysterious magic continues to captivate, and I look forward to continuing this journey through Prydain.

---

What’s Next from MJ Muñoz

In recent news, I’ve completed my book “Mockwing Mayhem,” a fantasy featuring magical bugs battling monsters. I’m currently finalizing cover art and developing the launch campaign.

For more information, visit grobugs.com. Sign up to receive a field guide to Mockwing Mayhem and the magical world of Grobugs!