Looking for clean, meaningful middle grade books? Author MJ Muñoz audits 30+ children’s and family-friendly reads—from timeless treasures to problematic picks.

Kid-Lit Audit: 30+ Middle Grade Books Reviewed: What I Loved, Loathed, and Would Never Give to a Kid |FF 17

0
Written by MJ Muñoz

Kid-Lit Audit: 30+ Middle Grade Books Reviewed: What I Loved, Loathed, and Would Never Give to a Kid – Fortress Fiction

What makes a middle grade book worth handing to a kid?

In this special episode, I audit 30+ children’s and middle grade books—from timeless classics to controversial favorites. Some are beautiful. Some are just fine. And some? I wouldn’t let my kids near them.

Let’s talk Little Women, Wings of Fire, The Secret Garden, Trapped in a Video Game, Tuck Everlasting, and more—plus what I’m doing differently in Mockwing Mayhem.

#amreading #middlegrade #bookreview #Book #FORTRESSFICTION #KidLit #Fantasy #MockwingMayhem #Parenting #StoriesWithSpine

VIDEO

My debut middle-grade novel is finished!

BUY MOCKWING MAYHEM NOW! LINK

My middle-grade fantasy novel, Mockwing Mayhem is out now!

Sinister Grimlings lurk in the shadows, hunting children. Only the Grobugs stand in their way. When a Mockwing—a mist-born Grimling—uncovers a hidden Grobug fort, it doesn’t attack alone. It summons a flock.

Now Chirp the bold and Quiver the cautious must face a battle they were never trained for. Outnumbered and outmatched, can they survive the onslaught and save their master?

Read it NOW to find out!

Subscribe to my newsletter for a FREE bonus story and updates on future books.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.

My Ultimate Middle Grade Book Audit

What I Loved, Loathed, and Recommend for Families

Welcome! I’m MJ—an author, artist, and analyzer. This post is my big kid-lit audit—a review of dozens of middle grade and children’s books I’ve read, assessed through the lens of quality, appropriateness, and staying power.

I believe in all-ages family fiction. That means books with heart, imagination, nobility, and truth. Some of the books below are incredible. Some are baffling. I’ll be blunt.

Let’s get into it.

Books I Loved (Top Picks)

These are the stories that resonated deeply with me—beautiful, clean, powerful, and timeless.

Little Women by Louisa May Alcott

One of the best books I’ve ever read. It’s top 10 material—charming, meaningful, and brilliantly written.

The Chronicles of Prydain by Lloyd Alexander

A masterful, approachable fantasy saga. If The Lord of the Rings is a rich feast, Prydain is a perfectly crafted home-cooked meal. Wonderfully balanced between light and dark.

Peter Pan by J.M. Barrie

Dark, poetic, and far deeper than any adaptation suggests. I did a full chapter-by-chapter review of this one and still think about it. A haunting classic.

The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett

Another domestic drama that lands beautifully. Full of healing, hope, and quiet transformation.

The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho

Technically YA, but a wonderful read for older children. Philosophical, romantic in a gentle way, and deeply uplifting.

The NeverEnding Story by Michael Ende

Far better than the movie. Deep, strange, and emotionally real. One of my favorites.

Bridge to Terabithia by Katherine Paterson

Grounded and fantastical all at once. A heart-wrenching and powerful story.

Number the Stars by Lois Lowry

A moving WWII story about bravery and sacrifice. Told through a child’s eyes, with care and power.

Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred D. Taylor

Raw, powerful, and deeply human. A must-read from the Logan Family Saga.

George MacDonald Collection

  • The Princess and the Goblin
  • The Day Boy and the Night Girl
  • The Wise Woman
  • The Princess and Curdie
    MacDonald’s work influenced Lewis and Tolkien—and you can feel it. These books are profound, moral, and magical. (The Light Princess, however, didn’t work for me.)

The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien

A joyful, epic little tale. I prefer it to The Lord of the Rings—it’s tighter, funnier, and still full of heart and heroism.

Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson

A fun, adventurous classic with surprising depth. Pure gold.

The Wizard of Oz Series (14 books) by L. Frank Baum

Whimsical and imaginative. Not perfect prose, but perfect spirit. A family treasure we’re reading aloud together.

The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood & King Arthur by Howard Pyle

Chivalrous, noble, and fun. I may be a Howard Pyle stan—and proud of it.

Good But Not Favorites

These books are worthwhile reads, even if they didn’t fully land with me.

Hatchet by Gary Paulsen

A solid, survival-focused story. Not a favorite, but highly effective.

Wind in the Willows by Kenneth Grahame

Quirky and layered. Not top-tier for me, but a strong story with clever absurdism and subtle satire.

Guardians of Ga’Hoole: The Capture by Kathryn Lasky

I only finished part of Book 1, but it was immersive and atmospheric. Definitely returning to it.

Ronia the Robber’s Daughter by Astrid Lindgren

Charming, but the ending felt weak. A solid, if not great, read.

The Red Panda Novels by Greg Taylor

Pulpy superhero adventures. Technically for adults, but clean enough for older kids. Fun, noble, and action-packed.

Books I Don’t Recommend for Kids

These were either poorly suited to children or had messages/themes I found troubling.

The Westing Game by Ellen Raskin

I found it morally confused and harmful for young readers. Contains marital infidelity, vandalism, and glorified deception.

Tuck Everlasting by Natalie Babbitt

Beautifully written but emotionally toxic. Hard no for kids.

Wings of Fire (Book 1) by Tui T. Sutherland

Too violent and romanticized for its target age group. Felt like dragon romance fanfic at times. May continue reading for research, but I wouldn’t hand it to a child.

Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll

Too absurdist and disjointed. No narrative arc or character growth to latch onto.

The Adventures of Tom Sawyer by Mark Twain

Inappropriate in tone and behavior for kids. Odd moral moments and romantic coercion played for laughs. Not one I’d recommend.

Honorable Mentions / Mixed Category

The Lord of the Rings & The Silmarillion by J.R.R. Tolkien

I love them—but they aren’t middle grade books. LOTR is rich but heavy. The Silmarillion feels like homework, except the Beren & Lúthien story.

Spiderwick Chronicles by Holly Black & Tony DiTerlizzi

Fun and magical, with slightly intense family drama. Appropriately emotional for many kids.

C.S. Lewis’s Space Trilogy

Great science fantasy… for adults. Not part of my kid-lit recommendations.

🎙 Fortress Fiction Reads (Podcast/YouTube Book Reviews)

Books I covered as part of my Fortress Fiction mission to explore meaningful, spine-strong middle grade stories:

Final Thoughts: What Makes a Good Middle Grade Book?

I believe great middle grade books should offer:

  • Moral clarity without preachiness
  • Joy and hope without fluff
  • Challenge without trauma
  • Depth without darkness

That’s the bar I hold as a parent, reader, and author—and it’s what I strive to write in Mockwing Mayhem.

Let’s Talk Books

Have you read any of these titles?
What’s your favorite (or least favorite) middle grade book?

Drop a comment below or tag me on Twitter @MJ_Scribe—I’d love to hear your take!

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.